Stepdad Father's Day shopping walks a line. Too generic and the gift reads as obligatory; too 'dad' and it may feel forced if the relationship is still new or the recipient does not call himself dad.
Set the quiz to 'My stepdad' for the relationship question. The quiz weights consumables, small experiences, and gifts rooted in shared moments higher than 'dad' specific keepsakes (custom 'dad' photo books, dad-themed signs).
Card language. 'For a wonderful stepdad' or 'On Father's Day' beats 'For dad' if the recipient does not actively call himself dad. If he does, follow his lead. The card sets the tone; pick wrong and even a great gift lands awkwardly.
Strongest picks. Small-batch BBQ rub flight ($32 to $65). Single-origin chocolate or coffee flight ($28 to $80). A round of golf for two he takes with someone of his choosing ($120 to $380). A framed photo from a recent family event ($30 to $80 framed). A small whiskey glass set plus a handwritten card naming a specific thing he has done well.
What to skip. Anything that calls the recipient 'dad' if he does not. Anything that ranks him against your biological dad. Generic stepdad-themed gifts that overcompensate for the dynamic.
If the relationship is new. Skew smaller and less personal. A nice consumable, a card with one specific thank-you, a small bottle of olive oil or a coffee bag. Save the larger and more personal gifts for years two and three when the relationship has settled.
If the relationship is established. Treat him as you would your dad. Larger keepsakes, experience gifts, engraved leather are all on the table.